The high-spec Astra offers lots of bells and whistles. But does it have the substance to impress our motoring correspondent?
By Tim Gibson
I was excited by the prospect of testing the Vauxhall Astra Elite Nav. The last Vauxhall I drove before that was the same spec Insignia, which I took on a photo shoot around the North Coast 500 in Scotland. After spending around 18 hours behind its wheel for four consecutive days, I concluded that it was one of the comfiest vehicles I’d driven. I even contemplated choosing one as my next company car.
So when I received the press booking for the Astra, my hopes were high. Here was a cost-effective vehicle that promised bags of spec and a gutsy 150PS engine with real-world fuel consumption that can top 50mpg. Based on the quality I’d experienced in its big brother, I thought it would prove a winner.
Alas, within a few minutes of plonking myself behind its steering wheel, my optimism faded. It’s not that the Astra is an unpleasant place to be. But it doesn’t quite hit the premium note that Vauxhall is clearly aiming for, especially with this Elite-spec variant.
The centre console is a mass of fiddly switches promising all sorts of riches: a heated steering wheel, three-mode heated seats, climate control, DAB digital radio, infotainment, sat nav, on-board cappuccino maker, holographic dancing girls, and so on. Actually, I made up those last two, but you get my drift.
Even with all the bells and whistles, the Astra can’t help but feel a little low rent against rivals such as the Volkswagen Golf, SEAT Leon, and Skoda Octavia. Even the long-in-the-tooth Volvo V40 is appealing by comparison, not least because the switchgear will feel just as solid in three years’ time as it does out of the box. The same can’t be said of the Vauxhall.
My biggest bugbear is the quality of plastics used on the door inserts. If you’re paying for a brand-new high-spec motor, I think it’s fair to expect something better than the sort of plastic most commonly seen on kids’ toys. Cheap doesn’t even come close.
Where the Astra scores well is performance. Get the turbo buzzing on that petrol lump and you can easily entertain yourself on a twisting country lane. It’s not quite a GTI (there’s a 1.6T 200bhp version for those who want real performance), but it’s certainly enough for most drivers.
The ride is pretty good, too. At slow speeds, the Astra can feel a bit twitchy over potholes and uneven asphalt. But put it on a flat piece of motorway and you feel as if you could cruise all day without breaking sweat.
When Vauxhall launched this generation Astra a couple of years ago, it made a big deal of its interior space. Compared to the model it replaced it was lighter and smaller on the outside, but far roomier for occupants. The result is ample head and legroom for front and rear passengers alike. But oh!, those seats. The leather-clad fascias look sumptuous and inviting, which only adds to the sense of disappointment when you settle onto something with all the comfort of a park bench. The back feels too upright, and it’s a job to believe there is any padding in the base at all.
Herein lies the rub with this car. From a distance, it looks as if it has everything to please a discerning buyer. Pound for pound, it offers far better value than the prestige brands mentioned above. But once you get near, you realise there’s a reason for the premium charged by the likes of VW.
Spending time with the Astra is a bit like discovering the Prada leather jacket you’ve been admiring on the internet is actually a PVC coat from Primark. It looks the part from afar, but simply doesn’t have the quality to match.
Still, if you’re working on a budget and want to maximise your spending power, the Astra is worth a look. For my money, the Golf or V40 are better options, even if you sacrifice a few toys along the way. But there’s clearly a market for what the Astra offers. Just look at the success of Primark.
Tim Gibson has written about cars for 25 years. His work regularly appears in The Daily Telegraph and other national media.
© Copyright Just Recruitment 2019
If you liked this article you may like to read – Just testing: Vauxhall Insignia Grand Sport 2.0 (170PS) Turbo D Elite Nav
You may also like to read – The future of work
|Sector:||Accountancy, Banking and Finance
|Salary:||£30,000 - £38,000|
The Just Recruitment Group have a superb opportunity for an experienced Management Accountant to join our client on a fulltime, permanent basis working near to Haverhill.
Reporting directly to the CEO of this fast growing successful company. The business is currently growing at 20% per annum and is at a pivotal moment in its development. New premises have been purchased and new sales and accounting systems are due to be installed in the coming 6 months. This role will be part of the senior management team and involved in key decision making for the business going forward.
The ideal candidate will possess the following skills:
|Sector:||Engineering and Manufacturing
|Salary:||£30,000 to £35,000 Per Annum|
This position is based nationally and reports to the Field Service Manager.
Monday to Friday 08:30 – 17:00 with a 60-minute unpaid lunch break. However, will be expected to work such additional hours as are necessary for the proper performance of your duties.
|Sector:||Accountancy, Banking and Finance
The Just Recruitment Group is currently recruiting for a Site Financial Controller on a one year fixed term contract, for a global manufacturer based at their site in Sudbury.
Working a 37.5 hr week Monday - Friday
25 Days annual leave + bank holidays
Occasional travel to the other UK sites will be required
The Primary responsibility for this role is to be accountable for the accounting and controls environment statuary and legal compliance.
Key Responsibilities include but not limited to:
The ideal candidate would have qualifications with a recognised accountancy body and preferably experience working in the manufacturing industry. Knowledge of SAP, Microsoft office is essential.
The purpose of this role is to work closely and business partner with the CFO, Directors and BU Leaders to guide the operational and strategic direction of various departments, therefore the role will involve some travel to various UK sites and possibly HQ in Germany.
|Sector:||Transport, Logistics and Shipping
|Salary:||discussed on application|
The Just Recruitment Group Ltd is currently looking to recruit an Export Freight Forwarding Coordinator for their client based in Dunmow, Essex.
Role will involve:
Would suit applicant with experience of working in a busy freight forwarding environment and who has the ability to build and develop relationships with both customers and suppliers.
40 Hour week - covering between the hours of 9.00 am - 6.00 pm. Monday to Friday.
i.e 8.00 am - 5.00 pm, 8.30 am - 5.30 pm, 9.00 am - 6.00 pm.
Holidays: 28 days including Bank Holidays
|Salary:||£18,000 – £20,000|
Just Recruitment is currently looking to recruit a Technical Sales assistant on behalf of a manufacturer in Sudbury.
This position will be office based, working within the team to help grow and maintain the customer database.
Monday to Friday 8am-5pm / 8.30am-5.30pmundefined(Flexible)
20 days holiday plus bank
Standard gov pension
Salary £18,000- £20,000 negotiable depending on experience