Commoditisation and how to resist it

Every business sector runs the risk of devaluing its offer by making it too standardised, and recruitment is no exception. So how do you avoid the pull of commoditisation, asks Peter Foy.

In an age of mass production, it is unsurprising that many goods have become commoditised. The era of hand-built cars, furniture and even houses has passed. Nowadays, everything is made to a standard specification, packed neatly in a box, and constructed with painting-by-numbers ease.

But surely the service industries are able to resist such a drag to the lowest common denominator? Sectors like recruitment, for example, ought to be able to differentiate between providers so that buyers make informed choices about who to procure from.

Alas, not so. Because even industries that seem at first sight to be innately people-focused, and therefore impossible to standardise, have somehow become commoditised. So, for example, a one-size-fits-all approach is adopted in accountancy, legal advice, architecture and even health care.

Small wonder that recruitment has not escaped, therefore. In the business of which I am a director, Just Recruitment Group Ltd, there is a constant pressure to offer out-of-the-box solutions to our clients and candidates. Even when we’re supposed to be exquisitely attentive to the particular needs of an individual business or person, we’re all the time being pushed by economic forces to offer an off-the-peg service that fills vacancies as quickly as possible.

Now, for some of the work a recruitment consultant delivers, that’s only to be expected. According to the Recruitment and Employment Confederation (REC), more than three quarters of the economic value of our industry in 2016 came from placing temporary workers. Given that many such appointments are what we term “arms and legs” roles – i.e. finding people who can perform fairly routine tasks with minimal training – it makes sense that our part in the process would be commoditised. Put bluntly, the people we’re supplying are treated as commodities, so why should our part in their recruitment be any different?

The push towards commoditisation is given impetus by advances in technology and the capacity to crunch big data to match candidates with vacancies. Because so much of the recruitment process can now be automated – and quite right, too, because it fills vacancies with far greater efficiency than in the past – it can be difficult to discern what the recruitment agency adds in terms of value. Or, to be more precise, it can be hard to see what any particular agency adds, making it seem a matter of no consequence which one you choose.

But this is where an attempt to resist commoditisation could well enhance the service a company like Just Recruitment delivers to clients and candidates alike. Following the advice of a report by management consultancy Roland Berger entitled Escaping the Commodity Trap (2014), smart businesses in all sectors are redefining themselves and developing their offer.

For our business, commoditisation prompts entrepreneurialism and a desire to add value. For example, rather than simply providing arms and legs to work on a production line, we can manage the whole process, effectively enabling the client to outsource their production processes to us.

That may seem like a big leap from basic recruitment, but it’s a natural development of what we do. After all, we’re sourcing candidates, often managing payroll and HR functions, and have a keen grasp of the processes they’ll be engaged in once in post. So why not take the whole thing over, thereby developing a more sophisticated model that takes even more strain away from our clients?

Another example of the way we can bring more depth to our offer is through the use we make of big data. For while it can seem to reduce the role played by the recruitment consultant in the appointments process, the data itself is only of value if analysed. And who better to develop such analytics than a recruitment specialist?

So, for example, a company like Just Recruitment could provide predictive analytics to clients that enable them to anticipate staffing needs and therefore be proactive in recruitment, rather than reactive. We could even use analytics to identify HR problems before they arise, optimising business performance and assisting staff motivation.

After more than 30 years in business, we have a sizeable amount of our own data to draw on. And if the whole industry worked together, perhaps facilitated by a trade body such as the REC, we would have a huge amount of aggregated data to use, enabling the discernment of trends and patterns, as well as longitudinal mapping over an extended period.

Of course, that would involve surrendering one aspect of our competitive advantage over each other – i.e., the value of our data. But given that it is in all of our interests to add value to our work and deliver a more sophisticated service to our clients, it strikes me as a risk worth taking.

Few experts have addressed the question of whether an entire industry can work together to resist commoditisation. The likes of Professor Howard Yu, for example, have focused on the ways individual players can differentiate themselves from competitors. But I wonder if a joined-up, industry-wide approach will help restore the professional status of recruitment, and give us a level playing field when it comes to winning business.

With that in place, success will be achieved by building long-term relationships of trust and reciprocity with clients and candidates. In short, it will put soft skills back at the heart of the industry. Commoditisation will have been resisted, and our value to clients restored.

More importantly, it will put people back at the centre of the recruitment process – which is surely the best thing for everyone involved. 

© Copyright Just Recruitment 2018

If you liked this article you may like to read – Why it's time for the recruitment industry to think big

You may also like to read – How will the Taylor review affect your business?

Jobs currently available

New job
Warehouse Operative
Sector: Warehouse
Salary: £12.25 - £13.07 per hour
Location: Snetterton
Role: Full Time
Contract: Permanent
Job ref: 913715
About the role

Just Recruitment is working with a growing organisation, based near Snetterton, to recruit a Warehouse Operative on a permanent basis to their long-standing team.

The key purpose of this role is to ensure that all items are correctly received and packed to meet company requirements.

Duties include:

  • Operating MHE safely and effectively according to requirements
  • Unloading goods-in
  • Checking in goods
  • Putting away products, keeping the warehouse tidy
  • Picking products as per order requirements
  • Checking orders, ensuring accuracy
  • Packing orders to ensure safety in delivery
  • Loading deliveries
  • Undertaking any other duties as may be required
  • Using WMS

Key skills required:

  • Good level of numeracy and literacy
  • Basic PC skills
  • Knowledge of company's health and safety policy
  • Housekeeping awareness
  • Qualifications to operate Bendi/Flexi
  • Physically active

Please note that this is a very manual-based role; you will need to be able to lift heavy items safely.

Due to the company’s location, you must have access to your own transport.

This is a great opportunity to join a friendly team.

 

Just Recruitment acts as an employment agency for permanent roles.
The salary advertised is the bracket available for this position. The actual salary paid will be dependent on your level of experience, qualifications and skill set.
We are an equal opportunities employer and welcome applications from all suitable candidates.

 

Read more
New job
Brand Coordinator
Sector: Customer Service
Salary: Discussed on application
Location: Braintree, Essex
Role: Full Time
Contract: Permanent
Job ref: 913714
About the role

Just Recruitment is supporting a well-regarded business based in Braintree who are recruiting for a Brand Coordinator to add to their team.

This role will involve working closely with Account Managers on new developments, handling samples of new products and sending them to the client for approval.

Duties will include:

  • Liaising with design to generate new artwork and amend existing artwork correctly
  • Liaising with purchasing at UK and international sites to obtain pricing and sampling quotations, and updating the CRM/Creator system accordingly
  • Handling customer enquiries and complaints efficiently and resolving them to a successful resolution
  • Producing periodic reports when required for the Account Manager and the client
  • Monitoring stock usage of certain products and taking ownership for ordering stock within company guidelines
  • Setting up brand manuals to include order forms, procedures, item references and prices
  • Keeping department code lists and size charts up-to-date
  • Liaising with the international sites regarding customer and retailer enquiries in regard to the production and dispatch of products
  • Keeping the CRM/Creator updated with all relevant artwork required for each brand
  • Assisting order processing as and when required, paying attention to detail

Working hours: Monday to Friday, 8.30am to 5.00pm.

 

Just Recruitment acts as an employment agency for permanent roles.
We are an equal opportunities employer and welcome applications from all suitable candidates.

Read more
New job
Counterbalance Forklift Driver
Sector: Production and Stock Control
Salary: £12.70 per hour
Location: Halstead, Essex
Role: Full Time
Contract: Temporary to Permanent
Job ref: JT-HAL-CFD-0725
About the role

Just Temps seeks an experienced Counterbalance Forklift Driver looking for a fresh start with a company in Halstead, Essex, that values hard work and reliability. This could be the opportunity you’ve been waiting for.

What’s in it for you?

This is more than just a job – it’s a chance to build a long-term career. Starting on a temporary basis, this role offers the genuine opportunity to go permanent. You'll be joining a close-knit team within a growing business where your efforts are recognised and rewarded.

About the role:

  • Operating a Counterbalance forklift safely and efficiently
  • Loading and unloading deliveries
  • Moving stock within the warehouse
  • Supporting the wider warehouse team with general duties
  • Maintaining a clean and safe working environment

Hours:

  • Monday to Friday
  • 6.00am to 2.00pm
  • Weekly pay
  • Ongoing support and progression opportunities

What we’re looking for:

  • A valid Counterbalance forklift licence
  • Previous warehouse or forklift experience
  • A strong work ethic and a team-player mindset
  • Punctuality, reliability, and attention to detail

This is a fantastic opportunity to secure stable, long-term work with the potential to grow within the company.

 

Just Temps acts as an Employment Business for the supply of Temporary Staff.
The salary advertised is the bracket available for this position. We are an equal opportunities employer and welcome applications from all suitable candidates.

 

Read more
New job
Procurement Manager
Sector: Purchasing and Merchandising
Salary: £40,000 - £50,000 per annum
Location: Sudbury
Role: Full Time
Contract: Permanent
Job ref: 913713
About the role

Just Recruitment is working with a growing manufacturing business, based on the outskirts of Sudbury, to recruit a Procurement Manager to join their growing team.

About the role:

  • The primary purpose of this role is to lead the procurement function in delivering greater strategic and operational value, supporting the achievement of key business objectives.
  • This is a hands-on, strategic and operational role that requires a confident leader with deep procurement expertise and the ability to inspire and develop a team.
  • You will work closely with the Supply Chain Manager to shape and implement a fit-for-purpose procurement strategy, ensuring alignment with business goals across quality, cost, sustainability and risk management. This role is pivotal in maintaining robust and value-driven supplier relationships while enabling continuous improvement in all procurement activities.
  • You will also oversee raw material planning and call-offs, ensuring that the business maintains the right balance between availability and inventory control — essential for production continuity and working capital efficiency.
  • This role includes direct line management of a Procurement Specialist, supporting their development and day-to-day activity management.

Key duties include:

  • Develop and implement a comprehensive procurement strategy aligned with business objectives, operational needs and sustainability goals.
  • Identify, evaluate, and manage suppliers across raw materials, packaging, and indirect categories to ensure quality, continuity and cost-effectiveness.
  • Collaborate with the Supply Chain Manager and other departments to align procurement with broader supply chain goals and business plans.
  • Contribute to the company’s sustainability, traceability and ethical sourcing commitments through strategic supplier partnerships.
  • Oversee the procurement of raw materials, packaging, indirect goods and services, and CAPEX items, ensuring optimal quality, cost and delivery performance.
  • Manage tendering processes, contract negotiation and supplier onboarding activities.
  • Ensure the ERP system is updated and used effectively for procurement activities and reporting.
  • Monitor and report on procurement KPIs, savings and supplier performance metrics.
  • Build and maintain strong relationships with key suppliers and service providers, driving continuous improvement and innovation.
  • Lead supplier performance reviews, audits and corrective action processes.
  • Identify and assess risks within the supply base and implement mitigation strategies to ensure business continuity.
  • Lead, mentor and develop the procurement team to achieve high levels of engagement, performance and professional growth.
  • Foster a culture of accountability, collaboration and continuous learning within the team.
  • Support the wider Supply Chain team by contributing to cross-functional initiatives and projects.
  • Ensure adherence to company procurement policies, financial controls and ethical standards.
  • Support internal and external audits with relevant documentation and compliance reporting.
  • Drive process improvement initiatives and embed best practices across the procurement function.
  • Build and nurture key working relationships with Production, Quality Assurance, Finance, Warehousing, Sales and Commercial Teams, Suppliers, Logistics Providers and Regulatory Bodies.

This is an excellent opportunity to drive change within a business — offering a great working environment.

Working hours for this role are Monday to Friday, 8am to 5pm — although some flexibility is required.

Please note that due to the location of the business, you must have access to your own transport.

 

Just Recruitment acts as an employment agency for permanent roles.
The salary advertised is the bracket available for this position. The actual salary paid will be dependent on your level of experience, qualifications and skill set.
We are an equal opportunities employer and welcome applications from all suitable candidates.

 

Read more
New job
Production Operative
Sector: Production and Stock Control
Salary: £12.21 per hour
Location: Hadleigh
Role: Full Time
Contract: Temporary to Permanent
Job ref: JT-HAD-PO-0725
About the role

Just Temps is excited to be supporting a fantastic company based in Hadleigh, assisting with the search for dedicated Production Operatives to join their friendly and fast-paced team.

This is an immediate start, temp-to-perm opportunity role!

You will be working in a clean, well-organised working environment, and full training will be provided — no previous experience required.

This role involves:

  • Manual production work
  • Standing on your feet and using your hands for the majority of the shift
  • Supporting day-to-day operations on the production line
  • Following health & safety procedures at all times

What we’re looking for:

  • A strong work ethic and attention to detail
  • Reliability and punctuality are essential
  • Own transport – the site is not accessible by public transport
  • Safety shoes and long workwear are required

If you're ready to start immediately and want to be part of a stable, supportive team, we’d love to hear from you.

Hours:

  • 8 hour shift
  • Day shift
  • Monday to Friday
  • No weekends
  • Overtime

 

Just Temps acts as an Employment Business for the supply of Temporary Staff.
The salary advertised is the bracket available for this position. 
We are an equal opportunities employer and welcome applications from all suitable candidates.

 

Read more