Forget about the difference between a private- and state-school education, says Tim Gibson. It’s the workplace that creates social mobility
By Tim Gibson
For the first 17 years of my life, this country had state-educated Prime Ministers. Both Margaret Thatcher and John Major attended local grammar schools – selective, certainly, but by no means benefiting from the big-money fees associated with elite independent schools.
Fast-forward two decades and the political world seems to be dominated by privately educated people. The two candidates vying to be our next PM both attended high-profile independent schools (Eton for Johnson and Charterhouse for Hunt), and recent statistics reveal that private school alumni have a disproportionate hold on top jobs such as senior judges, government ministers, diplomats and newspaper columnists.
At first sight, it is easy to claim schooling as the deciding factor in a person’s life chances. That is certainly what former education secretary Justine Greening concluded in a recent article in which she spoke of the “privilege bias [that] is hardwired into our education system.”
|"Rather than pointing to schooling as the deciding factor in social mobility, it's time to focus on the role of employers"|
But, as Greening also admitted on BBC Radio 4’s Today Programme, it is impossible to stop parents “wanting the best for their children” and seeking a private education if they can afford it.
After all, if you have the money and can see the doors such an educational experience opens, why wouldn’t you grasp it with both hands for your beloved offspring?
Knowing that the chances of banning public schools like Eton are slim (though that’s exactly what some pressure groups, such as Labour Against Private Schools, are calling for), and that such a move may well have a detrimental impact on our education sector as a whole, it seems as if we need to move the focus of discussion.
Rather than pointing to schooling as the deciding factor in social mobility, it’s time to focus on the role of employers in improving a person’s life chances.
Take John Major as a case in point. He left school at the age of 15 with just a handful of O levels to his name. After a few years of moving from job to job, he joined the banking sector and quickly enjoyed success. In his autobiography, he speaks of his work ethic once in a professional environment: he followed correspondence courses to further his career and worked with diligence and enthusiasm as his efforts were rewarded.
If employers establish a culture of opportunity, there is no reason why staff from every sort of background can’t thrive. It’s about giving people an opportunity to discover their talents, demonstrate their ability and grow.
It is striking that the jobs not dominated by privately educated people tend to be those where raw ability makes the difference between success and failure. According to a report by the Sutton Trust and Social Mobility Commission, just 5pc of footballers come from an independent school, and only 16pc of university vice chancellors were privately educated. Likewise, the creative industries are seen as a wellspring of social mobility.
This all shows the importance of talent management in the workplace. Employers need to be open to candidates of every background, looking for their potential to develop within an organisation and contribute to its flourishing in the long term.
And, with as wide a talent pool as possible, they need to invest in their people, giving them opportunities to garner further qualifications or develop their experience, whatever their age.
That way, the social mobility gap will narrow. People who haven’t been able to develop a wide range of talents during their formative years in education can have the encouragement to do so in the workplace, instead. We all know that late bloomers can enjoy extraordinary success, and are often happier than those for whom success comes earlier in life.
The problem with the current debates about social mobility is that they focus too much on schooling, so that it becomes determinative of a person’s life chances. By implying that the only reason Johnson and Hunt are able to stand for the Conservative Party leadership is because of their private education, we discourage those who have ordinary backgrounds from believing they could one day be in such a position.
But consider this: of the six Prime Ministers we’ve had since I was born, only two were privately educated (David Cameron and Tony Blair). Broaden that figure to include all leaders of the two main political parties in the same period (nine in total), and you’ll find that it only adds one person to the list of private school attendees (staunch socialist Jeremy Corbyn, funnily enough).
All of which suggests that we may be overstating the impact of education on political success, as in others areas of professional life. What matters is that people of all ages and backgrounds are given the opportunity to shine, regardless of their career pathway. When employers set up the conditions in which that can happen, by investing in their people and encouraging their growth, social mobility, not privilege, will be hardwired into our society.
Published June 16, 2019
© 2019 Just Recruitment Group Ltd
If you enjoyed this piece, you may like: Why encouragement is the greatest motivator
You may also enjoy: Inspirational people: Billie Jean King, tennis player, equal rights campaigner
|Sector:||Accountancy, Banking and Finance
|Salary:||£22,000 per annum|
Just Recruitment is recruiting for a permanent position on behalf of a company based in Braintree, Essex.
The main purpose of the role will be to provide a professional and timely accounting service in respect of all invoice and expense payments through the Purchase Ledger.
|Sector:||Public Service and Administration
|Salary:||£19,000 - £20,000 per annum|
Are you an experienced Mortgage Administrator looking for your next role?
Just Recruitment is recruiting for a Mortgage Administrator on behalf of a leading Estate Agency based all over East Anglia.
You will have regular liaison with lenders to obtain updates on application status, progress mortgages through to offer stage and liaise with solicitors until completion.
You will also process incoming mail, handle telephone enquires and liaises with Financial Advisors and the Sales Team.
Due to the location of this role, you must have your own transport – you will also be expected to visit the branch network around the county!
This is a full-time, permanent position.
If you are interested then apply today!
|Sector:||Accountancy, Banking and Finance
|Salary:||£25,000 - £30,000 per annum|
Just Recruitment is recruiting for an experienced Credit Controller on behalf of a company based on the outskirts of Sudbury.
The main purpose of this role is the ensure that the customer credit accounts are paid within the agreed terms. You will have the ability to demonstrate a high degree of competency in analytical thinking, troubleshooting and problem-solving.
Competitive salary plus benefits.
Skills and experience:
|Sector:||Engineering and Manufacturing
|Salary:||£20,000 - £25,000 per annum|
*Please note this is a part-time role!
Just Recruitment is delighted to be recruiting for a Maintenance Engineer on a part-time basis, for a well-established business on the outskirts of Halstead.
You will be required to provide immediate support in the event of machinery breakdowns and maximise the plant availability on a range of process and packaging lines.
Proactively improving equipment operation to reduce machine downtime and increase production efficiency is certainly a key element of this role.
You will be carrying out tasks with minimal supervision and conducting work appropriately and safely - ensuring all machinery and services are in good working order, ready for production use, including servicing and repairs of all equipment on site.
Working hours are flexible and can be revised - pay rate depends on experience and hours worked.
Excellent company benefits and free parking are on offer.
|Sector:||Engineering and Manufacturing
|Salary:||discussed on application|
Do you have an analytical or problem-solving mindset?
Are you looking for an exciting opportunity within a busy engineering/maintenance team?
Just Recruitment is recruiting for an ambitious Maintenance Electrician on behalf of a company based in Braintree, Essex.
You will interact with several departments to ensure that their manufacturing processes continue to deliver world-class products as efficiently as possible through efficient preventative maintenance, emergency breakdown response and continuous improvement initiatives within the manufacturing areas. You will deliver manufacturing targets by ensuring the process equipment is maintained to a world-class standard. The maintenance group will assist in projects to deliver quality, productivity, safety and cost reductions.
What will you do?
How will you get here?
Hours of Work:
Monday – Thursday 07:30 – 16:00.
Friday – 07:30 – 15:00.
39 hours per week.
Please note that if you have not been contacted within 7 days, your application for this position has been unsuccessful. Just Recruitment Group Ltd, are only able to process applications from candidates who are currently resident and eligible to work in the UK.