The general election campaign is awash with misinformation. It’s time to sort the “facts” from the truth, says Tim Gibson
By Tim Gibson
There’s something wrong with our political debate just now. I’ve written about that topic elsewhere, and don’t intend to cover the same ground here.
But what I will say is that a lot of the heat of the debate rests upon a mishandling of the truth. It’s a philosophical problem rather than a political one.
|I’m concerned with the accuracy or otherwise of assertions made by politicians and their supporters for its own sake.|
That’s quite a claim, so let me substantiate it. I’m concerned with the accuracy or otherwise of assertions made by politicians and their supporters for its own sake. But I’m interested, too, because of what it tells us about the way “truth” is viewed in contemporary society.
But at a more fundamental level, I’m interested in what these sorts of debates show us about the nature of truth, and the ways it is handled in political discourse.
That sounds pompous, doesn’t it? But, really, it’s at the very heart of this campaign. It has to do with the rampant subjectivism at work in so much political debate. All we’re seeing is an expression of opinion, a series of subjective judgments that have little grounding in objective reality, and even less concern to locate such grounding.
That’s worrying enough in its own right. If politicians, the people who are trusted to make decisions on the basis of the will of the electorate, whose opinions they are forming through their electioneering, aren’t worried about the facts, it’s a big problem.
But an even bigger problem is that it has led to an erosion of truth in general: a downgrading, such that no one is concerned about anything other than the expression of personal opinion. It greatly impoverishes public debate.
More worrying still is the attempt to dress up information that is the very opposite of truthful as grounded in fact.
Jeremy Corbyn appears on TV waving a redacted document that he claims prove the NHS is “up for sale” in Boris Johnson-led UK-US trade negotiations. Reasonably enough, everyone assumes that’s exactly what the document does say.
In fact, the detail is more nuanced: namely, that the people involved in those initial discussions (representatives of Theresa May’s government, not Boris Johnson’s) recognise that the US delegation would like the prices paid for pharmaceuticals to be a consideration in any trade deal. It doesn’t say they’re going to let that happen, still less sell off chunks of the NHS.
But, because Mr Corbyn brandished a piece of paper, his assertions took on the status of fact. Even though the facts are actually a little different.
|...there’s something especially troubling about a society in which truth is not only downgraded, but misrepresented.|
It’s the same on every side of the political divide. Mr Corbyn’s stunt came after he was put in the dock by broadcaster Andrew Neil for Labour’s complicity in anti-Semitism. But, as the BBC has recently made clear in its reporting, most people accept that there is no evidence that Jeremy Corbyn is himself anti-Semitic. The charge against him is that he's failed to show leadership in relation to those parts of his party where anti-Semitic sentiment has been expressed.
This nuance is often lost when his critics try to characterise him as anti-Semitic. It’s easier just to assume he’s racist than it is to engage with the detail of the debate.
And that’s where notions of truth and truthfulness come in. Because there’s something especially troubling about a society in which truth is not only downgraded, but misrepresented. A world in which subjective opinion and mere assertion take on the status of “fact”.
There is only one way to combat this: find reliable sources of information and consult them thoroughly before reaching judgment about a story.
The Full Fact website is a good place to start: an independent charity, dedicated to countering the culture of misinformation.
We also need to think carefully about the nature of truth. We need to recognise the difference between ideology and reality. And we need to understand how to handle the tension between the subjective and the objective.
The only way to do all this is through constructive dialogue, rather than the shouting match that has been this general election campaign so far.
© 2019 Just Recruitment Group Ltd
Published: 3 December 2019
If you enjoyed this article, you may like: We need a better politics, and it needs to happen in person
You may also enjoy: Want to get into classical music? These five pieces will help
Back Up Care is recruiting for a Care Coordinator for their Colchester Office to work on the busy Healthcare desk.
Previous experience in scheduling care and support staff would be preferred and a healthcare background is an advantage. You will be extremely confident and well-presented and be able to use your own initiative.
This position will involve working alongside the Office Manager, supporting them with the day to day running of the desk.
The role will include:
This requires you to work at an extremely fast pace, placing candidates into both temporary and permanent placements to match their qualifications, skills and experience.
There is a large amount of telephone calls liaison with candidates and clients, therefore excellent clear communicational skills are a must and excellent interpersonal skills are essential.
Other essential skills are:
28 days holiday including public holidays, increasing to 33 days after 2-year service.
If you wish to apply for this role, please forward your CV to firstname.lastname@example.org
|Sector:||Engineering and Manufacturing
|Salary:||Discussed on application|
Our client is seeking an experienced Quality Assurance Manager to join them on a permanent, full-time basis. This opportunity offers stability, longevity and professional development.
Reporting directly to the MD, the Quality Assurance Manager will be responsible for:
|Salary:||£22,000 per annum|
Just Recruitment is delighted to be supporting a well-regarded organisation at the forefront of its sector that is looking to add a Customer Service Administrator to its team, due to growth – based on the outskirts of Halstead.
The main purpose of the role is to service current and prospective customers by receiving and processing orders, enquiries and general information in a timely and courteous manner.
Key tasks include:
Key requirements for the role:
Previous experience requirements:
Offering free parking and an excellent working environment, this is a great opportunity to join a growing team.
Working Monday to Friday 37.5 hours per week - offering a competitive salary and company benefits.
|Sector:||Engineering and Manufacturing
|Salary:||£8.91 per hour|
Want to work in a safe, clean environment?
And have the possibility of ongoing work?
Just Recruitment is recruiting for a Temporary Production Operative to be based in Needham Market.
8.30am - 5.00pm Monday to Friday
|Sector:||Transport, Logistics and Shipping
|Salary:||£24,000 per annum|
Just Recruitment is delighted to be supporting, a well-regarded, family-run business on the outskirts of Ipswich.
You will be responsible for assisting with the loads out operation of the business by ensuring that the process from collection to arrival at the final destination is fully supported by the relevant goods in haulage documentation.
You will also be supporting the sales function of the business by dealing with customer queries in terms of both sales and operations as well as assisting with various ad-hoc marketing campaigns. This is a very varied role and requires flexibility, commitment and a substantial desire to learn and grow with the flourishing business.
Duties will include: