Workplace dilemmas: should I make my big promotion permanent?

Workplace dilemmas: Should I make my big promotion permanent?

A tricky teaser for our agony uncle this month: what to do if you’re acting up, but want to act down again

Dear Tim,

Towards the end of last summer, I was asked by my line manager to take her job. She’d secured an internal promotion and a part of her new role would involve restructuring our company. We’re a fairly well known global brand and have a huge headcount.

    ...the new job has put me under a huge amount of pressure. It might not have shown at work, but I think my friends and family would agree...  

My boss’s brief was to merge a couple of departments and she wanted me to take over as head of our team while the new structure was put in place. Then, she said, I’d have the opportunity to apply for a permanent role, heading up the merged department.

Naturally, I jumped at the chance. I’d been labouring away in my current job for a number of years. To be honest, I’d felt a bit as if my career was stalling and had begun looking around for new opportunities.

Then this came up: six months to prove myself, working on 10 grand a year more pay, with the chance to make it a long-term role if I delivered the readies.

Now here we are. The six months are almost up and I’ve been invited to apply for my position permanently. During a recent appraisal, my boss said I’d done a really impressive job at holding the team together during the time of transition. There have been a few redundancies, and the hierarchy thought I’d dealt with the challenge of that well.

Apparently, I’ve also shown good strategic instincts and strong people-management skills.

Workplace dilemmas: Should I make my big promotion permanent?While it’s lovely to receive such positive feedback, and good for my ego to be told that there’s a very high chance I’d be given the job on a permanent basis, I’m wondering if it’s really what I want.

By the time I’ve paid tax and National Insurance and lost my Child Benefit payments because the new salary puts me over the threshold, my £10,000 bounty doesn’t add up to much.

And the new job has put me under a huge amount of pressure. It might not have shown at work, but I think my friends and family would agree that I’ve been a lot more preoccupied since taking it on.

But I worry what will happen to my reputation if I decide not to apply for the full-time promotion and revert instead to my former job. Will that be the end of my career? Will I ever have a chance to assume more responsibility in the future, or is this a one-time-only thing?

Tim writes:

I’d like to begin by congratulating you. It’s no mean feat to assume additional responsibility with your existing employer, especially on a pro tem basis. Colleagues are often uncertain how to respond to you in such circumstances: all the time the job’s temporary, you’re still one of them. But then again you’re not, because you have to manage them and, as you found with the restructuring, are making decisions that could affect their futures.

To emerge from such an experience with your reputation not only intact but enhanced is deeply impressive. It is no surprise your boss wants to give you a more senior appointment permanently. You’ve clearly made your mark.

    To emerge from such an experience with your reputation not only intact but enhanced is deeply impressive.  

However, as bestselling author and motivational speaker Milly Johnson says, just because you’re good at something doesn’t mean you have to pursue it.

You may well be an exceptional manager who could go all the way to the very top of your profession. But if it’s not making you happy, what’s the point?

That said, you’re right to think about the optics of this. Your superiors will no doubt have taken your willingness to act up since the summer as an indication that you’re ambitious. Turning your back on the permanent opportunity could be interpreted as a step back from this. It could be seen as a sign that you’ve reached your level and don’t want to go any further.

Ultimately, though, that may be a risk worth taking. I imagine staff churn in a big company like yours is fairly high. Managers come and go. Which means the corporate memory is fairly short. At worst, the current crop of senior managers may have you pegged as unambitious if you don’t take this opportunity to make your elevation permanent.

Should you change your mind about pursuing preferment a few years from now, the chances are new managers will be in post. And they won't be hung up on this incident because it will have happened before their watch.

Nothing we do in the present locks us in forever. To sound like a walking cliché, your happiness and mental wellbeing are more important than anything.

If you don’t feel that this is the time to take the permanent promotion, don’t take it. Go back to your old job, knowing that you have to let go the opportunity to continue shaping things. Reclaim your Child Benefit. Live a simpler, less stressful life.

But consider this. How will you feel if someone else comes in and does “your” job? It may be that you’re feeling anxious about stepping up permanently. Get over that diffidence and this could be just the opportunity you’ve been looking for to keep your career fresh and your working life interesting.

© 2019 Just Recruitment Group Ltd

Published: 8 January 2020

If you enjoyed this article, you may like: Workplace dilemmas: my colleague doesn’t respect my religious beliefs

You may also enjoy: Workplace dilemmas: how do I help my colleague through mental illness?

Jobs currently available

New job
QA Manager
Sector: Engineering and Manufacturing
Salary: Discussed on application
Location: Saffron Walden
Role: Full Time
Contract: Permanent
Job ref: 910873
About the role

Our client is seeking an experienced Quality Assurance Manager to join them on a permanent, full-time basis. This opportunity offers stability, longevity and professional development.

Reporting directly to the MD, the Quality Assurance Manager will be responsible for:

  • Maintaining and improving the Company's Quality Management System and ensure internal compliance
  • Working with all departments to ensure their procedures are being followed and to improve their internal and cross-functional processes and procedures
  • Ensure that the quality of current and newly introduced products is compliant and traceable
  • Coordinate Quality activities with all over departments
  • Develop and improve quality relationships with all customers of the Company
  • Responsible for all Quality activities and personnel in the Quality Department for the Company
  • Provide strong leadership in the day-to-day operations of the Quality department and mentor the members of the team
  • Establish performance goals for all departmental employees and monitor performance on a continual basis
  • Oversee all hiring, appraisal, training and discipline of Quality personnel
  • Member of the Company's Management team
  • Produce the Quality element of the company's annual Budget
  • Formulate the departmental strategy aligned to the overall Company strategy
  • Embed a Continuous Improvement culture within the Quality Dept and contribute to the Continuous Improvement programme across the site


  • HND or equivalent qualification in Engineering or a related technical field required
  • Minimum 5 years experience in a Manufacturing environment
  • Ability to articulate (verbally and in writing), defend and negotiate Quality expectations with internal and external customers at all levels of management
  • Good interpersonal skills with the ability to guide and educate/train at all levels
Read more
New job
Customer Service Administrator
Sector: Customer Service
Salary: £22,000 per annum
Location: Halstead
Role: Full Time
Contract: Permanent
Job ref: 910871
About the role

Just Recruitment is delighted to be supporting a well-regarded organisation at the forefront of its sector that is looking to add a Customer Service Administrator to its team, due to growth – based on the outskirts of Halstead.

The main purpose of the role is to service current and prospective customers by receiving and processing orders, enquiries and general information in a timely and courteous manner.

Key tasks include:

  • Answering incoming calls, giving product information, lead times, dealing with general enquiries and queries, redirecting calls to relevant departments
  • Raising and inputting orders and proforma invoices
  • Raising quotations
  • Amending orders, as required
  • Scanning documentation
  • Liaising with Areas Sales Managers and responding to their requests
  • Arranging couriers and/or carriers as required
  • Any general office associated duties

Key requirements for the role:

  • Excellent computer skills
  • Good eye for detail
  • The ability to work well under pressure
  • Courteous

Previous experience requirements:

  • Previous Customer Service Administrative experience gained within an office environment
  • Excellent telephone manner with the ability to communicate at all levels
  • High level of attention to detail and accuracy
  • Good working knowledge of Microsoft Office and experience of in-house systems
  • Ability to multi-task and prioritise own workload
  • Exceptional communication skills, both written and verbal
  • Understanding of the importance of data protection and adherence to the process

Offering free parking and an excellent working environment, this is a great opportunity to join a growing team.

Working Monday to Friday 37.5 hours per week - offering a competitive salary and company benefits.

Read more
New job
Production Operative
Sector: Engineering and Manufacturing
Salary: £8.91 per hour
Location: Needham Market
Role: Full Time
Contract: Temporary
Job ref: 910811
About the role

Want to work in a safe, clean environment?
And have the possibility of ongoing work?

Just Recruitment is recruiting for a Temporary Production Operative to be based in Needham Market.

Duties include:

  • Ensure all final and completed products are packed to the customer specifications                               
  • Informing Line Leaders of defects found in the products
  • Keep machines supplied with packing materials and labels
  • Assist the Line Leaders with handovers and changeovers
  • Responsible for general cleanliness of the production area and removal of production and general waste
  • Check products on the line for quality and defects
  • Basic production duties carried out in a fast-paced environment

Working hours:

8.30am - 5.00pm Monday to Friday

Read more
New job
Logistics Coordinator
Sector: Transport, Logistics and Shipping
Salary: £24,000 per annum
Location: Ipswich
Role: Full Time
Contract: Permanent
Job ref: 910869
About the role

Just Recruitment is delighted to be supporting, a well-regarded, family-run business on the outskirts of Ipswich.

You will be responsible for assisting with the loads out operation of the business by ensuring that the process from collection to arrival at the final destination is fully supported by the relevant goods in haulage documentation.

You will also be supporting the sales function of the business by dealing with customer queries in terms of both sales and operations as well as assisting with various ad-hoc marketing campaigns. This is a very varied role and requires flexibility, commitment and a substantial desire to learn and grow with the flourishing business.

Duties will include:

  • Process orders and oversees the order to completion of paperwork
  • Facilitate the shipping of products from one destination to another
  • Arrange transportation with outside hauliers
  • Receive paperwork from the Weighbridge department and check and complete the paperwork within the allocated time allowed
  • Answer calls and emails relating to customer queries and log them on the CRM system and resolve any outstanding issues raised
  • Keep CRM records up-to-date
  • Work with the sales and operations team to ensure that high customer service levels are achieved and delivered to all customers you are responsible for at all times

Skills required:

  • Good Microsoft skills including Word, Outlook & Excel
  • Ability to work proactively on an independent basis as well as be a good team player
  • You will have the interpersonal skills necessary to develop and sustain effective relationships with team members of other departments and with all customers
  • Good attention to detail and analytical skills
Read more
Legal Secretary (Part-Time)
Sector: Law and Security
Salary: Up to £11.00 per hour
Location: Witham
Role: Part Time
Contract: Permanent
Job ref: 910868
About the role

Just Recruitment is delighted to be supporting an established business, based in Witham looking to add a highly-skilled secretary to their long-standing team.

The role will involve, audio typing, preparing documents, answering the phone, dealing with enquiries and assisting colleagues as well as directing queries as needed.

Key responsibilities to include:

  • Audio typing – dictation
  • Preparing letters and drafting documents
  • Handling diaries and booking appointments
  • Answering the phone and dealing with queries
  • General secretarial and office-based duties

As well as having experience in a secretarial position, you will have audio typing experience and excellent typing skills. The role requires you to have a good level of IT literacy, experience of Word (essential) and Excel would be useful. You will take pride in your work and have a caring and sympathetic nature.

Please note this role is part-time.

This is a great opportunity, offering a good pay rate and company benefits.

Read more
Accounts Assistant
Sector: Accountancy, Banking and Finance
Salary: £9.50 - £10.00 per hour
Location: Sudbury
Role: Full Time
Contract: Permanent
Job ref: 910867
About the role

Just Recruitment is delighted to be supporting, a well-regarded, family-run business on the outskirts of Sudbury.

They are looking to add an Accounts Assistant with payroll experience to their team.

Key duties include:

  • Responsible for weekly and monthly payroll’s on Sage and all related duties (holiday forms etc.)
  • Knowledge of Xero accounts
  • Purchase Ledger
  • Sales Ledger
  • Chasing payments
  • Exporting mail-order invoices and credit notes from Magento to Xero
  • Assist Bookkeeper with any accounts duties
  • Assist Bookkeeper with HR Duties as needed
  • Reconciling Braintree payments to Mail Order invoices
  • Assist with stocktaking and valuation

Knowledge of Xero and Microsoft Office would be advantageous, although Sage experience would be considered. Attention to detail, good time management skills, accuracy, approachable and reliability is a must.

Free parking is available on site, offering a competitive hourly rate and an excellent working environment.

Read more